Online Voting Policy

Rules of Procedures for Online Voting

We no longer us the eV voting process. Our new organization allows us some flexibility for voting. We will make sure votes are not rushed through without adequate notice.

The articles of association of the OpenEmbedded e.V. provide that certain decisions can be taken by online voting. This includes voting about new members and deciding about certain rules of procedures. In addition the OpenEmbedded e.V. allows to use online voting for decisions which aren't covered in the articles of association. There are several different types of votes which slightly differ in procedure and method to calculate results. These rules regulate the procedure of online votes and how results are calculated. The intention of these rules is to provide a fair and pragmatic way to let the OpenEmbedded e.V. take decisions by online voting.

Voting Administrators

The board of the OpenEmbedded e.V. assigns one or more voting administrators which are responsible for technically performing the voting. This includes sending out the ballots, receiving the votes, calculating and publishing the results.

The voting administrators must not disclose any information about the identity of the voters or any other information which isn't contained in the published voting results.

General procedure for online voting

An online voting is initiated by a voting proposal followed by a discussion period. After the discussion period the voting period is started. The voting is finished by calculating and publishing the voting results.

Results of online votes are effective immediately following publication of the results unless otherwise stated in the voting proposal.

Voting Proposal

An online voting is initiated by a proposal for voting which states the subject of the voting. The proposal is sent by email to the membership mailing list and has to include exact and complete information what is voted upon. Only the information which is directly included in the mail sent as voting proposal is subject of the voting.

The voting proposal email has to explicitly be marked as voting proposal by starting the email subject line with the string "Voting Proposal:".

Any active member can initiate a voting by sending a voting proposal.

The member who has initiated a vote can retract the voting proposal by sending an email to the membership list stating the intention to retract the proposal.

A proposal can only be retracted within the discussion period.

Discussion Period

The discussion period begins on the date the membership mailing list receives the voting proposal. Unless specified otherwise in the procedures for the specific type of vote (see: Types of Votes), the discussion period lasts for two weeks. The discussion period should be used to discuss the voting and form opinions about the options which are available for voting.

Start of Voting

When the discussion period has finished the voting is started by sending ballots to all active members. The ballots should include the text of the proposal which is voted about.

Voting Period

The voting period is started by sending out the ballots. Unless specified otherwise in the procedures for the specific type of vote (see: Types of Votes), the voting period lasts for two weeks. During the voting period the active members cast their votes. Only votes cast within the voting period are considered for the results of the voting.

End of Voting

After the voting period all cast votes are counted and the results of the voting are published.

The results of a vote are published to the OpenEmbedded e.V. membership by sending them to the membership mailing list. They have to include the number of persons permitted to vote, the total number of votes, and the number of votes for each available voting option. The results should also include a statement, if the voting was valid according to section 5.

Types of Votes

There are three types of votes: Votes about new members (3.1), elections of groups of people (3.2), votes for decision (3.3).

Voting about new members

The discussion period is started by sending a new member proposal to the membership mailing list. Within the discussion period at least two other members have to declare their support for the vote, otherwise the proposal is considered to be rejected. If two members declare their support the voting is started after the discussion period.

The discussion period has a duration of one week and is extended to two weeks, if requested by a member.

The voting period has a duration of one week.

For new member votes there are three options: "Yes", "No", "Abstention". The new member is accepted, if there are more "Yes" than "No" votes and the vote isn't invalid according to section 5.

Electing groups of persons

For elections of groups of people there is an additional candidacy period before the voting proposal is sent. The person responsible for the execution of the voting sends a call for candidates to the membership mailing list which starts the candidacy period. If there is no explicit rule about who is responsible for execution of the voting, the board of the e.V. is responsible.

The candidacy period lasts two weeks. All members who declare their candidacy in a statement sent to the membership list become candidates for the election.

After the candidacy period the list of candidates is sent as voting proposal. This starts the two-weeks discussion period.

The candidates are voted on as options according to section 3.4.

Voting about decisions

The OpenEmbedded e.V. can officially take decisions or decide about official statements on request of at least three active member. One member has to send the voting proposal to the membership mailing list. This starts the discussion period. Within the discussion period at least two other members have to declare their support for the vote, otherwise the proposal is considered to be rejected. If two members declare their support the voting is started after the discussion period.

The responsible party for execution of the voting sends the voting proposal which includes all options. This starts the discussion period.

After the discussion period the voting is started. The options are voted on according to section 3.4.

Voting System

Multiple options

If there are more than two options (excluding abstention), the following voting system shall be used:

The members are asked to rank the options in terms of their preference into a ballot. A ballot may contain two options of the same rank. All options must be ranked. Each member may make up to one ballot.

The winners are found by:

  1. Given two options A and B, V(A,B) is the number of voters who prefer option A over option B.
  2. From the list of options, we generate a list of pairwise defeats.
         * An option A defeats an option B, if V(A,B) is strictly greater than V(B,A).
  3. From the list of pairwise defeats, we generate a set of transitive defeats.
         * An option A transitively defeats an option C if A defeats C or if there is some other option B where A defeats B AND B transitively defeats C.
  4. We construct the Schwartz set from the set of transitive defeats.
         * An option A is in the Schwartz set if for all options B, either A transitively defeats B, or B does not transitively defeat A.
  5. If there are defeats between options in the Schwartz set, we drop the weakest such defeats from the list of pairwise defeats, and return to step (iii).
         * A defeat (A,X) is weaker than a defeat (B,Y) if V(A,X) is less than V(B,Y). Also, (A,X) is weaker than (B,Y) if V(A,X) is equal to V(B,Y) and V(X,A) is greater than V(Y,B).
         * A weakest defeat is a defeat that has no other defeat weaker than it. There may be more than one such defeat.
  6. If the number of options in the Schwartz set does not exceed the number of required winners, then the winners are the Schwartz set. If the number of members of the Schwartz set exceeds the number of required winners, the board chooses which of the members of the Schwartz set wins.
  7. If this results in an insufficient number of winners, then the candidates which have already won according to step (vi) should be removed from the list of options, and then this procedure is repeated from step (i).

Parts of this section are copied from the Constitution for the Debian Project (v1.4), http://www.debian.org/devel/constitution

Two options

If the number of options is exactly two (excluding abstension), then:

   * Each active member can vote with "Yes", "No" or "Abstain".
   * If there are more "Yes" than "No" votes and the vote isn't invalid according to section 5, the decision is accepted.

Right to vote

All members of the OpenEmbedded e.V. which are active members at the time the voting period is started have the right to cast a vote. The prerequisite for taking part in online votes is a valid email address in the member database. The member is solely responsible for initially setting and updating his email address in the member database.

Quorum

The result of a voting only becomes effective when the number of votes which have chosen an option different from "Abstention" is greater than 20 percent of the number of active members. If this quorum isn't reached the voting is considered invalid. An invalid voting can be repeated, but not before a period of four weeks has passed between publishing the results of the invalid vote and the proposal for the repeated voting.

Anonymity

Online votes are anonymous. The information which members participated in the vote and for which option they voted aren't disclosed. The voting administrators are allowed to track this information for technically executing the vote. The information mustn't be used for other purposes and mustn't be made available to any other people.

Publication of voting results

All voting results except for rejected votes about new members are published on the OpenEmbedded e.V. web site, excluding the exact numbers of votes.

Modification of voting procedure

The board may modify the voting procedures for individual votes upon request of the e.V. membership if good reason for the change, as determined by the good judgment of the board, is provided.